Two new homes for sale on the former Cottonwood Mall site in Holladay come from the same builder. Tri Pointe Homes has a 2,067-square-foot townhome at Aspire listed at $779,900. It also has a 5,576-square-foot estate home at 4915 South Memory Lane in Pavilions listed at $4,448,000. The estate is about 2.7 times the size of the townhome and about 5.7 times the price. Working that out per square foot, the townhome is about $377 and the estate is about $798.
Once you compare the homes within each tier, the pattern is the same at both ends of the site. The biggest part of the price pays for getting into a tier, and each extra square foot after that costs much less. For anyone comparing new construction in Holladay with the established streets around it, that matters more than any single price.
One site, four communities
The Holladay Hills master plan calls for more than 600 living units and up to 750,000 square feet of office, dining, shopping and entertainment space. We wrote about the retail and coworking side in Holladay's Saturday Now Has Two Centers of Gravity. This post covers the homes for sale. Tri Pointe has four communities planned on the site: Aspire, Pavilions, Crestview and Horizon.
| Community | Status on the builder's pages | Size range | Price as published by the builder |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aspire townhomes | Now selling | 1,969 to 2,522 sq. ft. | From the $700s |
| Crestview | Coming soon, early 2027 | 3,419 to 5,147 sq. ft. | Anticipated from $1.3 million |
| Pavilions estate homes | Now selling | 5,201 to 8,010 sq. ft. | Listings at $4,239,000 and $4,448,000 |
| Horizon | Coming soon, 2027 | 1,241 to 2,533 sq. ft. | No price posted |
All the prices in this post are the builder's asking prices as shown on Tri Pointe's community pages at this writing. None of them are closed sales, and a new home's price can change as later homesites release.
What the extra square foot costs inside each tier
The two Aspire listings make the pattern easy to see. A 2,067-square-foot plan was listed at $779,900, and a 2,511-square-foot plan at $898,900. The larger plan costs $119,000 more for 444 more square feet, or about $268 for each added foot. That's well below the roughly $377 per foot for the smaller home as a whole. In this tier, the larger home is the better value per foot.
Pavilions works the same way at a much higher price. Pavilions at Holladay Hills is a collection of six estate homes with four-bay garages, and the builder's community summary gives a range of 6 to 7 bedrooms and 8 to 9 baths across the plans. The community address is 2045 East Arbor Lane. The two homes listed now are smaller than that range suggests. 4929 South Memory Lane is listed at $4,239,000 for 5,201 square feet with four bedrooms, and 4915 South Memory Lane at $4,448,000 for 5,576 square feet with five bedrooms. The smaller house costs more per foot, about $815 against $798. The extra 375 square feet in the larger home adds $209,000, which works out to about $557 per added foot.
The homes differ in floor plan, homesite and finishes, so these figures are a rough measure and not an appraisal. Still, the direction is the same in both tiers. Price per square foot falls as the home gets bigger, so it tells you little when you compare a townhome with an estate. Most of what a buyer pays for is the tier itself: a detached homesite or a shared wall, a four-bay garage or a townhome garage, and a set of six homes or a larger townhome community.
What the estate tier charges for
Tri Pointe describes the Pavilions homes as built around everyday wellness, with natural light, indoor-outdoor flow and Mount Olympus as the backdrop. In Builder and Developer, Tri Pointe COO Tom Mitchell said the concept is a response to buyers who want homes that support their wellbeing and adapt over time, as opposed to luxury defined only by size or finishes.
The Salt Lake Tribune covered the first finished example in August 2026. It's a six-bedroom home with interiors by designer Bobby Berk, a courtyard with a year-round pool and a view of Mount Olympus, and it is one of the six estate lots planned for Pavilions. The Tribune's headline used the designer's phrase "quiet luxury." The home was entry #4 in the 2026 Salt Lake Parade of Homes as "The LivingWell Home," marked for sale at $4.5 million and up. The Tribune's March 2026 tour described the model when it was mostly foundation and framing, with a bedroom window framed around a view of Mount Olympus.
So the premium at the top of the ladder is for a specific set of things: one of six detached homesites, a design program built around wellness, and the Olympus view. Buyers aren't paying $800 a foot for space. A larger estate home adds space at a much lower rate per foot.
The entry tier shows where the builder has room to move
The Aspire page currently advertises up to $35,000 in closing incentives on eligible homesites and a national promotion with first-year rates as low as 3.99% (5.522% APR) at participating Utah homesites. Tri Pointe estimates Aspire's HOA fee at $275 a month. Next to a price in the $700s, $35,000 is a meaningful amount. If you're shopping the townhome tier, the advertised incentive belongs in your math right next to the asking price. These figures are general information as published by the builder, not financial or tax advice, so confirm what applies to your own purchase with your lender and tax advisor.
The gap in the middle closes in 2027
Today the ladder has two working rungs about $3.4 million apart. Crestview, at 4873 South Pacific Crest Way, is meant to fill the space between them. It's planned as two-story homes of 3,419 to 5,147 square feet, anticipated from $1.3 million, with an opening expected in early 2027. Horizon, planned at 1,241 to 2,533 square feet, is also expected in 2027.
For a buyer in the $1.5 million to $3.5 million range, the timing matters. Crestview's sizes overlap the larger Aspire plans at the low end and approach the smallest Pavilions homes at the high end. Until it opens, a buyer in that range who wants a new home on this site has to step down to a townhome or up to an estate. Once it opens, the site will have a detached tier that competes directly with many established Holladay homes.
How this compares with the established streets
The surrounding neighborhood was making a similar trade long before the mall came down. In 2019 the Holladay Journal reported on the area around the Cottonwood Club, which was built on large lots in the early 1950s. Neighbors there described modest mid-century houses giving way to larger homes, and a home on Lone Peak Drive was demolished. That story is several years old. It describes the same basic trade as Holladay Hills, though. Buyers paid for the lot and the setting, and the square footage came after.
The two places get there differently. On the established streets, the setting comes with mature trees, a large lot and whatever house already stands there. At Holladay Hills, the setting is a new homesite inside a planned district with trails, parks and gathering spaces, a few minutes from the retail. Woodbury Corporation announced Trader Joe's for Holladay Hills in October 2025. A move-up buyer comparing a Pavilions estate with an older Holladay home on a big lot is comparing two kinds of setting. Price per square foot doesn't capture the difference. Our notes on what move-up buyers should look for in Holladay homes cover the established-home side in more detail.
A few common questions
Are these prices what the homes sold for? No. They are the builder's asking prices as published on its community pages. A closed price can differ once incentives and upgrades are included.
Which Pavilions homes are still to come? Tri Pointe's Pavilions page marks Homesites 3, 5 and 6 as coming soon, at 6,956, 6,811 and 8,010 square feet.
Is the Crestview price set? Tri Pointe describes it as anticipated from $1.3 million, ahead of an opening expected in early 2027.
If you're deciding between a new Holladay Hills home and an established home on one of Holladay's older streets, Whitney Foley Real Estate can line up the two options by tier, incentive and setting, so you know what each price is buying before you commit. Let's find your perfect property.